?

Log in

 
 
30 September 2008 @ 02:18 am
Results - Challenge 4 - Round 3  
Hi to all! Challenge 4 Round 3 voting is closed. Thanks to all who voted!


Eliminated:
Photobucket
reich_2

Sorry! Hope to see you next session! :)

People's choice:
Photobucket
by pursy
BANNER

Congrats!!!

Mod's choice:
Photobucket
by edckezia
BANNER

Maybe it's a little bit blurry, but I like crop and colouring! :)

Results:
01. +4
02. -3+2=-1
03. -2
04. +1
05. -5
06. +1
07. +2


Reasons:
negative:

# 2
-dont like crop and corners, think it's need more contrast
-crop isn't good, the part of the nose looks really bad
-I guess crop isn't nicely chosen. eye is too high but bottom part looks empty
# 3
-very good idea, but b&w effect really doesn't fit
-background change didn't really work, the icon is too busy
# 5
-too red color
-too pink or red coloring
-not so well quality. colouring could be much better
-the icon is way too dark
-too blurry

positive:
# 1
-very original!
-like using of textures
-nice cutting and background looks very good
-nice composition
# 2
-really good crop
-good colors, composition and idea are pretty
# 4
-nice soft coloring
# 6
-nice coloring and crop
# 7
-nice crop and quite suitable soft colouring
-nice crop
 
 
 
Yuliai_we_you on September 30th, 2008 11:16 am (UTC)
Congrats :)